Top 5 Carry-On Suitcase Comparison for Travellers in the US and UK
- Melanin Travels Magic
- 3 days ago
- 17 min read
A frequent traveler must- have expandable5 Carry-On Suitcases Comparison and Gift guide
Ever stood at the luggage carousel watching everyone else's bags appear while yours is nowhere in sight? We've all been there, and that's exactly why investing in quality best carry-on luggage is one of the smartest travel decisions you'll ever make. Whether you're a weekend warrior hopping between cities, a digital nomad living out of a backpack and carry-on, or a business traveler who needs to look sharp the moment you land, your carry-on is more than just luggage—it's your mobile wardrobe, office, and peace of mind all rolled into one sleek package.
But here's the thing: the carry-on market is overwhelming. Scroll through any online retailer and you'll find hundreds of options ranging from budget-friendly basics to investment pieces that cost more than your plane ticket. So how do you cut through the noise and find the one that's actually worth your money? What are the best carry-on suitcases for frequent travelers?
That's where we come in. We've tested, compared, and ranked five standout carry-on suitcases that represent the best of what's available right now—covering everything from Instagram-worthy aesthetics to business-ready functionality and budget-conscious picks that don't skimp on quality. This comprehensive carry-on suitcase review will help you make an informed decision.
Please Note: This article contains affiliate links. If you click through the links on this page and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission. We earn from qualifying purchases as an affiliate of Stay22, TravelPayout, and a few other travel brands. Thank you for supporting Melanin Travels Magic Blog. [Learn More]
Table of Contents
Introduction - [Read More]
What to Look for in a Suitcase (Before You Buy) - Best carry-on Suitcase Comparison
Our Top 5 Carry-On Suitcase Brands: Detailed Reviews - Best Suitcase Comparison - [Read More]
Side-by-Side Comparison Table - Best Carry-On Suitcase Comparison - [Read More]
Winner by Category: Our Expert Recommendations on the Best Carry-On Suitcase Comparison - [Read More]
Frequently Asked Questions About Carry-On Luggage - Best Carry-on Suitcase Comparison your questions answered - [Read More]
Final Verdict: Which Carry-On Suitcase Should You Buy? Which one is Best: Carry-On Suitcase Comparison- [Read More]
What to Look for in a Carry-On Suitcase (Before You Buy) - Carry-On Suitcase Comparison
Before we dive into our top picks, let's talk about what to look for in a carry-on suitcase. Trust us — knowing these key factors will save you from impulse-buying something that looks cute but falls apart after three trips. Let's Go: Carry-On Suitcase Comparison ready!
Size & Airline Compliance: Your Carry-On Suitcase Size Guide for Airlines
Here's the reality check: not all "carry-on" suitcases are created equal, and airline size restrictions vary more than you'd think. Most major carriers allow carry-ons measuring around 22" x 14" x 9", but budget airlines can be stricter. The sweet spot? Look for a bag that's 21-22 inches tall—it'll fit in most overhead bins without drama.
This carry-on suitcase size guide for airlines is essential: always check your specific airline's requirements before you fly, especially if you're traveling internationally where regulations can differ significantly.
Hard Shell vs Soft Shell: Which Is Better?
This is the age-old debate in the luggage world, and honestly, both have their merits when comparing hard shell vs soft shell carry-on suitcase options. Hard shell carry-on suitcases (usually made from polycarbonate) offer superior protection for fragile items, they're water-resistant, and they look undeniably sleek—perfect for that airport aesthetic.
Soft shell bags, typically made from ballistic nylon, are more flexible (easier to squeeze into tight spaces), often lighter, and usually feature exterior pockets for quick-access items. For most travelers, hard shell wins for durability and style, but if you're someone who chronically overpacks, soft shell's expandability is a lifesaver.
Essential Features That Matter - Carry-On Suitcase Comparison
Beyond size and material, here are the make-or-break features you should prioritize. Four-wheel spinner suitcase designs (360-degree rotation) are non-negotiable—they make navigating airports effortless. TSA-approved locks give you security without risking damage from airport security checks. Expandable designs add 1-2 inches of packing space when you inevitably buy too many souvenirs. Interior organization (compression straps, zippered pockets, wet compartments) keeps your belongings tidy and secure. Finally, consider weight—a lightweight carry-on means more room for your weight allowance.
Our Top 5 Carry-On Suitcase Brands: Detailed Reviews - Carry-On Suitcase Comparison
Now for the main event. We've put together a carry-on suitcase comparison featuring five brands that genuinely stand out in their respective categories. Whether you prioritize style, business functionality, budget, or innovation, there's something here for you in this best carry-on luggage roundup.
1. CALPAK Ambeur Carry-On – Best Stylish Carry-On for Women
If your Instagram feed is full of travel content and you believe that function and fashion should never be mutually exclusive, the CALPAK Ambeur is calling your name. This 22-inch beauty features a metallic polycarbonate hard shell carry-on that catches light like jewelry—available in show-stopping shades like Rose Gold and Silver that literally sparkle as you walk through the terminal. But it's not just a pretty face: the Ambeur is expandable (adding 2 inches of space when you need it), rolls smoothly on 360-degree spinner suitcase wheels, and includes a TSA-approved combination lock for security.
The interior is thoughtfully designed with zippered compartments and compression straps that keep everything organized, even during those chaotic hotel room packing sessions at 5 AM. User reviews consistently praise its durability, with travelers reporting it holds up beautifully even after multiple international trips. At approximately 22" x 14" x 9" (expandable to 11"), it fits perfectly in most overhead bins. The price point sits in the mid-range category, making it an accessible luxury for style-conscious travelers who refuse to compromise on quality.
Pros: Stunning metallic finishes, expandable design, lightweight yet durable, excellent interior organization
Cons: May show scratches on high-gloss finish over time
Best For: Fashion-forward travelers, content creators, anyone who wants their luggage to make a statement
Why you should get it & Expert Frequent Traveller tips:
We’ve used this lovely expandable carry on for a 2 week trip recently . It had a great capacity and looks so stylish, your real travel bestie
Get it on Amazon US:
Get it on Nordstrom UK :
2. Briggs & Riley Essential 22" – Best Carry-On for Business Travel
When you're traveling for work, you need luggage that works as hard as you do. Enter the Briggs & Riley Essential 22"—the MVP of business travel and one of the best carry-on suitcases for frequent travelers.
This soft side spinner suitcase features their proprietary CX compression and expansion system, which is basically magic: it lets you pack more without exceeding airline size limits, then compresses everything back down when you're done. The exterior-mounted Outsider handle maximizes interior packing space (a genius design move), and the SpeedThru pocket with RFID protection means you can keep your laptop accessible during security checks without fumbling.
But here's what really sets Briggs & Riley apart: their "Simple As That" lifetime warranty. No proof of purchase needed, no questions asked—if anything goes wrong, they'll repair or replace it. For frequent flyers who rely on their luggage, this is invaluable. The bag also includes a USB pass-through PowerPocket for charging devices on the go, self-repairing YKK zippers, and 360-degree spinner wheels with shock absorption for smooth navigation through crowded airports. At approximately 7.5 pounds, it's a lightweight carry-on enough to lift into overhead bins without breaking a sweat.
Pros: Lifetime warranty, compression system, business-friendly features, RFID protection, maximum interior space
Cons: Higher price point, soft side may not protect fragile items as well as hardshell
Best For: Business travellers, frequent flyers, anyone who values long-term investment over upfront cost
Why you should get it & Expert Frequent Traveller tips:
This bag is not only chic and lightweight, it’s a perfect addition for any long weekend escape or short getaway this winter.
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/4pp2Mhl
Get it on Briggs & Riley UK:
3. Samsonite Virtuosa – Best Travel Suitcase from a Trusted Brand - Carry-On Suitcase Comparison
Samsonite has been the gold standard in luggage for over a century, and the Virtuosa proves they're not resting on their laurels. This 21-inch polycarbonate hard shell carry-on combines classic reliability with modern innovation, making it a top contender in our best carry-on luggage comparison. The RightHeight handle system offers multiple one-inch adjustments, so whether you're 5'2" or 6'4", you'll find the perfect pulling height.
The bag expands by one inch when you need extra space, and the WetPak pocket is a thoughtful addition for storing damp swimsuits or toiletries without contaminating your clean clothes.
Weighing in at just 6.39 pounds, it's one of the lighter options on our list and truly qualifies as a lightweight carry-on, which matters when you're sprinting to catch a connection.
The interior features multiple zip pockets and compression straps to keep everything secure and organized. Samsonite's commitment to sustainability shines through with the recycled RPET interior lining—stylish and eco-conscious. The dual spinner suitcase wheels glide effortlessly, and the TSA-approved integrated combination lock provides security without bulk. Plus, the 10-year limited warranty gives you peace of mind. Often on sale at major retailers, the Virtuosa offers premium quality at competitive prices.
Pros: Lightweight, trusted brand reputation, adjustable handle, WetPak pocket, eco-friendly materials, frequently discounted
Cons: Less expandability than some competitors
Best For: Travelers who want tried-and-true quality, eco-conscious buyers, those seeking brand reliability
Why you should get it & Expert Frequent Traveller tips:
If You like to travel in style on a budget, we got you! Old money vibes for a fraction of the price and it’s currently on sale! Hard to resists.
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/3MfZSgu
Get it on Nordstrom UK https://shopstyle.it/l/cwKRW
4. BAGSMART Getaway 20" – Best Budget Carry-On Suitcase Under $100
Let's be real: not everyone wants to drop several hundred dollars on luggage, especially if you're just starting your travel journey or you're on a tight budget. The BAGSMART Getaway proves you don't have to sacrifice quality for affordability, making it the clear winner for best budget carry-on suitcase under $100.
This 100% polycarbonate shell carry-on regularly goes on sale for under $100, yet it competes with options that cost three times as much. The expandable design increases capacity from 35 to 42 liters (that's a 20% boost), and the GlideTech wheels with shock-absorbing technology roll surprisingly smoothly considering the price point.
At compressed dimensions of 21.7" x 13.8" x 9.8" (expanding to 11.4" deep), it fits airline requirements comfortably. The front-opening version includes a laptop compartment—perfect for digital nomads who need to work between flights. Waterproof wet/dry pockets keep your toiletries separate, and the TSA-approved combination lock provides security. Here's the kicker: BAGSMART offers a lifetime warranty AND a 100-day trial period. If you're not satisfied, return it. That kind of confidence in a budget product speaks volumes. Available in vibrant colors like Light Blue, it's proof that affordable luggage doesn't have to be boring.
Why you should get it & Expert Frequent Traveller tips:
Look, if you’re a fashionista the colour range will give you summer vacation & winter sun getaway vibes and compliment your best summer outfits! Why say more!
Pros: Unbeatable price, lifetime warranty, 100-day trial, expandable, GlideTech wheels, front-opening option
Cons: Heavier than premium options (~8 lbs), less refined aesthetics
Best For: Budget travelers, students, first-time luggage buyers, anyone who prioritizes value over prestige
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/44h1tZG
Get it on Amazon UK : Here
5. LEVEL8 Voyageur 20" – Best Design Innovation & Color Options
LEVEL8 might not have the name recognition of Samsonite, but the Voyageur 20" is turning heads with its innovative design features and bold color options. The three-layer Makrolon polycarbonate shell is built to last, with a luminous textured finish that resists scratches far better than glossy alternatives. The standout feature? A wider trolley handle design that creates more interior packing space—a clever engineering solution that makes a noticeable difference when you're trying to fit everything in.
With eight silent spinner suitcase wheels (yes, eight), the Voyageur glides through airports without that annoying rattling sound that echoes through quiet terminals at 6 AM. The aluminum telescoping handle adjusts to four height levels, and the built-in TSA code lock integrates seamlessly into the design. At 43 liters capacity and 21.3" x 15.1" x 9.8" dimensions, it maximizes space without exceeding carry-on restrictions.
The interior features spacious mesh pockets and compression straps. Available in sophisticated colors like Navy and Dark Olive, plus a striking Yellow/Black two-tone option, the Voyageur appeals to travelers who want their luggage to reflect their personality. The lifetime warranty on shell, wheels, handles, and zippers backs up the quality promise.
Pros: Innovative wide handle design, eight silent wheels, scratch-resistant finish, unique color options, lifetime warranty
Cons: Lesser-known brand, slightly heavier (8.1 lbs)
Best For: Design-conscious travelers, those who want unique colors, anyone seeking innovation in luggage design
Why you should get it & Expert Frequent Traveller tips:
If you’re looking another colourful, stylish carry on for your next European getaway or Island hopping escape alongside a smart design, packing will never be so easy and motivationa
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/3XdgBDx
Get it on Amazon UK : Here
Side-by-Side Comparison: Which Carry-On Suitcase Wins? - Carry-On Suitcase Comparison
To help you visualize the differences, here's a quick comparison table of our top five carry-on suitcases:
Feature | CALPAK Ambeur | Briggs & Riley Essential | Samsonite Virtuosa | BAGSMART Getaway | LEVEL8 Voyageur |
Material | Polycarbonate Hardshell | Softside (Ballistic Nylon) | Polycarbonate Hardshell | Polycarbonate Hardshell | Makrolon Polycarbonate |
Size | 22" (expandable +2") | 22" (expandable) | 21" (expandable +1") | 20" (expandable 20%) | 21.3" |
Weight | Lightweight (~7 lbs) | ~7.5 lbs | 6.39 lbs | ~8 lbs | 8.1 lbs |
Wheels | 4 spinner (360°) | 4 spinner (360°) | 4 dual spinner (360°) | 4 spinner (360°) | 8 silent spinner (360°) |
TSA Lock | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Warranty | Standard | Lifetime (No Receipt) | 10-year Limited | Lifetime | Lifetime |
Special Features | Metallic finishes, Instagram-worthy | CX compression, USB PowerPocket, RFID, SpeedThru pocket | RightHeight handle, WetPak pocket, eco-lining | GlideTech wheels, 100-day trial, front-opening option | Wide handle design, 8 wheels, textured finish |
Price Range | Mid-range ($200-300) | Premium ($400-500) | Mid-range ($200-300, often on sale) | Budget (<$100 on sale) | Mid-range ($150-250) |
Best For | Style & Fashion | Business Travel | Trusted Quality | Budget Buyers | Innovation & Design |
Winner by Category: Our Expert Recommendations - Carry-On Suitcase Comparison
After extensive testing and comparison, here are our top picks for different traveler needs in this best carry-on luggage guide. Your perfect carry-on suitcase depends entirely on what matters most to you, so we've broken it down by category to make your decision easier.
Best Overall: Samsonite Virtuosa
For the perfect balance of quality, features, price, and brand trust, the Samsonite Virtuosa takes the crown as the best carry-on luggage overall. It's a lightweight carry-on that's easy to handle, durable enough to last for years, and packed with thoughtful features like the WetPak pocket and RightHeight handle system.
The 10-year warranty and frequent sales make it an excellent value proposition. Whether you're a casual vacationer or a frequent traveler, the Virtuosa delivers consistent performance without breaking the bank.
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/3MfZSgu
Get it on Nordstrom UK https://shopstyle.it/l/cwKRW
Best for Style: CALPAK Ambeur
If you want luggage that turns heads and photographs beautifully, the CALPAK Ambeur is unmatched in this category. The metallic finishes are genuinely stunning, and the expandable design ensures you're not sacrificing functionality for aesthetics. It's the perfect choice for travelers who see their journey as part of their personal brand and want every element—including luggage—to reflect their style. Yes, it may show scratches over time, but the initial impact is worth it.
Get it on Amazon US:
Get it on Nordstrom UK :
Best for Business: Briggs & Riley Essential
Business travelers need reliability above all else, and the Briggs & Riley Essential delivers as one of the best carry-on suitcases for frequent travelers, featuring a lifetime warranty, compression system, and professional features like RFID protection and the SpeedThru laptop pocket.
The higher price point is justified by the quality construction and the promise that this could genuinely be the last carry-on you ever buy. When your livelihood depends on making that meeting across the country, you need luggage you can trust completely.
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/4pp2Mhl
Get it on Briggs & Riley UK:
Best Budget: BAGSMART Getaway
Quality luggage under $100? It seemed impossible until BAGSMART entered the market with the Getaway, earning its spot as the best budget carry-on suitcase under $100. This carry-on punches well above its weight class, offering features like expandability, GlideTech wheels, and a lifetime warranty at a fraction of the cost of premium brands.
The 100-day trial period eliminates purchase anxiety. For students, budget travelers, or anyone who doesn't want to invest heavily in luggage, this is a no-brainer.
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/44h1tZG
Get it on Amazon UK : Here
Best Innovation: LEVEL8 Voyageur
The Voyageur showcases what happens when a brand really thinks about the user experience and isn't afraid to try new approaches. The wide handle design creates noticeably more packing space, the eight silent wheels make airport navigation quieter and smoother, and the color options let your personality shine through.
If you appreciate clever design solutions and want something that stands out from the crowd without screaming for attention, LEVEL8 has created something special here.
Get it on Amazon US : https://amzn.to/3XdgBDx
Get it on Amazon UK : Here
Side-by-Side Comparison:
Frequently Asked Questions About Carry-On Luggage - Carry-On Suitcase Comparison
We've compiled the most common questions travellers ask when shopping for carry-on suitcases in this carry-on suitcase comparison guide. These answers will help you make an informed decision based on real travel scenarios.
What size carry-on fits most airlines?
The universal sweet spot for a carry-on suitcase size guide for airlines is approximately 22" x 14" x 9" (56cm x 36cm x 23cm), which fits most major carriers including American, Delta, United, British Airways, and Emirates. However, budget airlines like Ryanair, EasyJet, and Spirit have stricter requirements, sometimes limiting carry-ons to 21" or even 20" in height. Always check your specific airline's website before purchasing, and when in doubt, go slightly smaller—a 20-21" carry-on is more versatile across different carriers than a 22" bag.
Are hard shell or soft shell carry-ons better?
When comparing hard shell vs soft shell carry-on suitcase options, hard shell carry-on suitcases excel at protecting fragile items, repelling water, and maintaining their shape, plus they tend to look more polished and modern. Soft shell bags offer more flexibility for squeezing into tight overhead bins, they're often lighter, and exterior pockets provide easy access to laptops and documents. For most travelers, hard shell wins for durability and protection, but business travelers who need laptop accessibility might prefer soft shell with smart organizational features like the Briggs & Riley.
Q: How much should I spend on a carry-on suitcase?
Budget options ($50-100) like the BAGSMART Getaway — our top pick for best budget carry-on suitcase under $100 — can serve you well for occasional travel. Mid-range suitcases ($150-300) like the Samsonite Virtuosa and CALPAK Ambeur offer the best balance of quality and value for regular travelers.
Premium options ($400+) like Briggs & Riley are investments that come with exceptional warranties and features that justify the cost for frequent flyers. Consider how often you travel: if you fly multiple times per year, investing in the $200-400 range typically offers the best long-term value and durability.
Q: What's the lightest carry-on luggage?
Among our top picks for best carry-on luggage, the Samsonite Virtuosa leads at just 6.39 pounds empty, making it an exceptional lightweight carry-on that gives you maximum weight allowance for your belongings. Generally, hard shell polycarbonate bags under 7 pounds are considered lightweight.
Weight matters more than you think—when you're rushing through connections or dealing with stairs in cities without elevators, every pound counts. Just remember that ultralight bags sometimes sacrifice durability, so find the right balance between weight and construction quality.
Q: Do I need spinner wheels or 2-wheel luggage?
Four-wheel spinner suitcase designs (360-degree rotation) have become the standard for good reason—they let you push your suitcase alongside you instead of dragging it behind, reducing strain on your arm and shoulder. They're especially valuable in crowded airports where maneuverability matters.
Two-wheel luggage is more stable on uneven surfaces and inclines but requires tilting and pulling, which can be tiring over long distances. For airport-centric travel, spinners are superior; for rough terrain or cobblestone streets, traditional two-wheelers hold up better.
Q: Which carry-on has the best warranty?
A: Briggs & Riley's "Simple As That" lifetime warranty is unmatched among best carry-on suitcases for frequent travelers—they'll repair or replace your bag for life, no proof of purchase required, no questions asked. BAGSMART and LEVEL8 also offer lifetime warranties on their carry-ons, which is impressive for their price points.
Samsonite provides a solid 10-year limited warranty. When evaluating warranties, look beyond the length and check what's actually covered—some warranties exclude wheels and handles (the parts most likely to fail), while comprehensive warranties like Briggs & Riley cover everything.
Final Verdict: Which Carry-On Suitcase Should You Buy?
After all this research, comparison, and hands-on experience in this comprehensive carry-on suitcase review, here's our honest take: there is no single "perfect" carry-on suitcase for everyone, but there is a perfect carry-on for your specific needs and travel style based on what to look for in a carry-on suitcase.
If you're a frequent traveler who flies multiple times per month and needs absolute reliability, invest in the Briggs & Riley Essential. The lifetime warranty alone makes it worth the premium price, and you'll appreciate the business-focused features every single trip—making it one of the best carry-on suitcases for frequent travellers.
For travelers who want premium quality from a trusted brand without the highest price tag, the Samsonite Virtuosa is your best bet for best carry-on luggage. It's frequently on sale, weighs almost nothing as a true lightweight carry-on, and delivers consistent performance that justifies the mid-range investment.
Style-conscious travelers who refuse to compromise on aesthetics will find their match in the CALPAK Ambeur. Yes, you're partly paying for the Instagram-worthy design, but you're also getting solid functionality and quality construction that'll last through years of adventures.
Budget-conscious travellers should skip the ultra-cheap no-name brands and go straight to the BAGSMART Getaway—our best budget carry-on suitcase under $100. It's proof that affordability doesn't mean sacrificing quality, and the lifetime warranty shows the brand stands behind their product.
And if you appreciate innovative design and want something that feels fresh and different, the LEVEL8 Voyageur brings new ideas to the luggage space with practical features you'll notice every time you travel.
The bottom line? Any of these five carry-on suitcases represents a smart purchase. Consider your budget, travel frequency, style preferences, and specific feature needs. Read through user reviews on Amazon for real-world experiences. And remember: the best carry-on luggage is the one that makes your journey easier and more enjoyable, whether that means effortless rolling through terminals, turning heads with metallic finishes, or simply knowing you didn't overspend on something that does the job well.
Happy travels, and may your carry-on always fit in the overhead bin on the first try.
Are you ready for more for More Airport Layover Recommendations and Travel tips:
Are you inspired? Why not also read our other Layover and Travel trends articles to plan your next International trip well-prepared? If you are adding another Asian country your next South East Asia getaway … We got you!
Free City Tours That Will Electrify Your Next Airport Layover
How To Spend A Layover In Paris, France: Skip The Airport Lounge
Unveiling Qatar 20 Must-Do Activities for an Unforgettable Adventure during a long layover
8 Best Places to Eat Near Charles de Gaulle Airport While on a Long Layover in
Top 6 Tips for Solo Traveling as a Woman - Stay Safe & Happy!
Why You Need Shades of Melanin as Your Must-Have sun-safe Travel Companion this Winter:
Top 10 Gen-Z & Millennial Travel Trends Turning Heads in 2024
Disclaimer: Always check current travel guidelines and airport transfer times before planning your layover adventure.
Comments